We're having a hard time digesting that the report we published 2 weeks ago has had so many views http://bit.ly/cce8RM it's shocking really 8 hrs ago

Archive for the ‘Community Manager’ Category

Summary
The budding Community Manager industry holds 4 tenets; these values resonate as a common thread within the role. The include community advocation, brand ambassadorship, online communication skills, and product requirements gathering and improvements.

Methodology
Recently, I’ve been doing some research on the Community Manager role, which is appearing at most brands that take online communities and communication seriously. This was a role I had this role at Hitachi Data Systems, and many of my friends and peers have this role around the industry, and I’ve written about it extensively.

16 real job descriptions
I put out requests on Twitter, blog and email to get submissions, as well as scoured the public job listings and I’ve reviewed 16 job descriptions from companies ranging from LinkedIn, Buzz about wireless (Sprint), Vancity, Communispace, Imagination Corp, Microsoft, Flock VMware, GamesforChange, Disney, ACDsee, Dogster, SimplyHired, Yahoo, and many others. It was a global sample from B2B to B2C, and the beliefs and values that these individuals require in the job description indicate a direct pattern.


The Four Tenets of the Community Manager
In the following, I’m not going to list out all my findings, but it was clear there were 4 number of Tenets, or beliefs that each role holds. In nearly all the job descriptions, the following beliefs were spelled out as requirements for the role.

1) A Community Advocate
As a community advocate, the community managers’ primary role is to represent the customer. This includes listening, which results in monitoring, and being active in understanding what customers are saying in both the corporate community as well as external websites. Secondly, they engage customers by responding to their requests and needs or just conversations, both in private and in public.

2) Brand Evangelist
In this evangelistic role (it goes both ways) the community manager will promote events, products and upgrades to customers by using traditional marketing tactics and conversational discussions. As proven as a trusted member of the community (tenet 1) the individual has a higher degree of trust and will offer good products.

3) Savvy Communication Skills, Shapes Editorial
This tenet, which is both editorial planning and mediation serves the individual well. The community manager should first be very familiar with the tools of communication, from forums, to blogs, to podcasts, to twitter, and then understand the language and jargon that is used in the community. This individual is also responsible for mediating disputes within the community, and will lean on advocates, and embrace detractors –and sometimes removing them completely. Importantly, the role is responsible for the editorial strategy and planning within the community, and will work with many internal stakeholders to identify content, plan, publish, and follow up.

4) Gathers Community Input for Future Product and Services Perhaps the most strategic of all tenets, community managers are responsible for gathering the requirements of the community in a responsible way and presenting it to product teams. This may involve formal product requirements methods from surveys to focus groups, to facilitating the relationships between product teams and customers. The opportunity to build better products and services through this real-time live focus group are ripe, in many cases, customer communities have been waiting for a chance to give feedback.

While there is much deeper research on this role to be completed such as where are they, how much do they make, who do they report to, best practices, etc, I’ll just be publishing the above. Thank you so much to all those who’ve submitted content to me.

Additional Resources
I’ve been very involved with this new role, here’s some related content:

  • Meet your peers and Join the Community Manager group in Facebook
  • Understanding the Community/Evangelist Role, and profiles of a few of my Favorite Folks
  • Capture from the Community UnConference
  • Forum One Community Roundtable–Strategies for Community
  • Video of Dell: When the Web team leads product development, the evolution of Dell Hell to Dell Swell
  • Video: Web Strategy Show: Community Strategies with Jake McKee
  • Update: Also see this association of community managers (IOCMA) that are now calling for members (link via Connie)
  • (Update: based upon comment feedback, I modified the language of this 4th tenet for clarification, thanks Shashib, and Connie)

    (Update 2: Kevin adds a lot to the conversation and challenges the idea that “They aren’t your communities to manage“, also read Evan’s response to Kevin.)

    The following is an exclusive interview with Alex de Carvalho, the Community Manager of Scrapblog.

    I learned that pictures can really help tell a story, you’ll see that I use images in many of my posts from events, conferences, or interviews. The web brings a rich experience that helps us humans convey meaning, emotion and stories.

    Even if your company isn’t an image based company (like Scrapblog) you can use photos to enhance your online communications.

    I was impressed with the great photos that I was seeing out of the BlogHer conference this past week, as Alex (his personal blog), the Community Manager at Scrapblog had been publishing photos he poste on Flickr of their “photobooth”.

    I wanted to know more, so he agreed to this interview:


    Jeremiah: Alex, Scrapblog attended the recent BlogHer conference, which attracts a great deal of women bloggers, what’s this have to do with Scrapblog?

    Alex: With Scrapblog, you take your media a step further. You may combine your photos and videos with text, stickers and backgrounds to create collages, slideshows or scrapbooks. We launced in April and so far about three-quarters of our users are female, many of whom are bloggers. So BlogHer was an ideal conference to get to know and connect with our user base.

    Jeremiah: I was impressed and amazed to see all the great looking pictures on your Flickr account, what’s the story?

    Alex: We partnered with BlogHer to run a sweepstakes: the lucky winner got a trip to the BlogHer Conference in Chicago. At the conference, we set up a photo-stand area at the exhibitor’s hall using backdrops designed by Veerle Pieters. We had ordered a bunch of props, boas, glasses, picture frames and hats, including the very popular flamingo hat. When people came to talk to us and to get their t-shirts, onesies, stickers and other swag, they would also pose for a fun photo. Cindy Li and Tara Hunt came up with the photo-stand idea and Carlos Garcia, Caleb Elston, Jordan Fulghum and I had a great time helping out!

    Jeremiah:I know that Scrapblog relies on images and pictures to build its unique product, but how did you use images in the context of the event?

    Alex: In addition to pictures of the speakers, conference attendees, Chicago and so on, we though it would be fun to have a photo stand to take original, colorful and unique pictures. Within Scrapblog, you may use a variety of themes, backdrops, props, stickers, patterns and such. The photo area was a fun way to show what these backdrops and props would look like in “real life”. We think it was a great match for the event: for most attendees, BlogHer is also an opportunity to meet other bloggers in a fun setting and the photo-area turned out to be a great way to capture some of those memories.

    Jeremiah: What will you be doing with these images?

    Alex: We took hundreds of picures and right after the conference created a series of scrapblogs with the images. We also posted them to Flickr in this set and also in this year’s Blogher07 Chicago group. The images are also all tagged blogher07 and sbboothblogher07 so they may be found easily within Flickr and within the Scrapblog Builder, using the Flickr API.

    Jeremiah: Give me some practical tips for other Community Managers to use those digital cameras at events.

    Alex: I think I can learn from you, judging from your Flickr photostream! I think it boils down to telling a story with your pictures, taking interesting photos and being generous by taking as many pictures as you can. Let people know where you will publish your pictures so they may find them later. When uploading to Flickr, describe what each picture is about in the title, tags or description. Hyperlink them in the description field and add them to relevant groups. Encourage others to take pictures and tell the story from their point of view. Then, find these pictures and comment when appropriate. These basic tasks make a significant difference over time.
    I upgraded to a DSLR camera this year and focused on learning how to shoot higher quality pictures than previously with a point-and-shoot. I also process them in Adobe Lightroom and/or Photoshop prior to publishing, to adjust the white balance, contrast and saturation. It takes a bit longer, but I think the jump up in quality is worth it.

    Jeremiah: What’s next for Scrapblog? What’s in the works?

    Alex: We’re very happy with the Scrapblog Builder and are regularly updating it with new photo editing features and new themes from leading designers. We are now working out the new functionalities for our site which will make it easier for you to find, visualize and interact with scrapblogs and with the Scrapblog community. We’ve got lots of great stuff planned!

    Be sure to check out my other text based interviews, or watch the Web Strategy Video Show.


    Alex

    Alex de Carvalho, photo by Josh Hallett

    Dell’s blog champion, Lionel Menchaca spends time with me to talk about some of new programs that they’ve put out over the last year. From the Dell blog, IdeaStorm, and how they’re adapting to the needs of customers.

    This video is a bit outdated, as Dell has done a few other things since I filmed this, so be sure to see the chronology at the Dell Social Media Saga Timeline.

    Questions I asked regarding IdeaStorm: “Isn’t getting product requirements for the computers the role of the product team? Not the web team?”

    What has Dell done that’s so great? Over a year ago, they were getting beat up very badly on blogs, support, and exploding laptops. Now in 2007, they’ve launched a blog, are creating videos and sharing, and have even created the revolutionary “IdeaStorm” website that lets customers tell Dell what features they want on their products. The most shocking? Many of them said they don’t want Microsoft Windows (A strategic partner of Dells) on it, what did Dell do? Watch the video to find out.

    Dell is quickly leading the social media space for corporations, as they’ve really embraced the changes, have empowered customers to make decisions about products. That’s revolutionary.


    I was able to interview Jake McKee, the Community Guy, in Austin Texas. He shares some key strategies on building a community program, finding consultants, and the do’s and do nots. Jake’s background?

    “Jake McKee is an evangelist for online and offline community building, social media, and customer-company interaction. He has been working with online communities, fan groups, and consumer groups since the early days of the Internet, and has a rich background in Web development, community management, business strategy, and product development.”

    Although I turn my phone off, and ask others to as well, I apologize for the cell phone interference noises, I suspect that was from others around us.

    My respected friend Lionel Menchaca at who runs the community programs over at Dell exchanged a series of emails this last week. A former sales employee of Dell released a series of tips on how customers can ‘work the system’ to get the best deals for a Dell computers.

    Dell asked for the post to be removed by the consumerist who posted the information, they refused. Lionel, the blog warrior at Dell is working hard to open up the company to build better products, have open lines of communication and do what’s right was sick, and was unable to respond during the chaotic exchanges.

    Later, Lionel released this apology, which according to the 120 something comments was a sincere apology. Corporations, which are run by humans, make mistakes. Corporations that give human, sincere apologies can win back customers.

    Lesson: The power of media control is shifting, corporations that embrace this change stand to benefit, and um, Lionel, I hope you’re feeling better.

    I’ve known Robyn for over a year, we used to be members of the Podcast roundtable and have spent hours debating, discussing RSS, Marketing, Analytics. The MyBlogLog team has been very fortunate to snag her as their new Community Manager. There’s celebrations everywhere!

    I can’t say enough great things about her outward and friendly persona, she’s also techie geek, loves video games and can do a great job representing both her company and the community. From one blogger to another, I congratulate you Robyn! (Martin does too)

    Her biggest challenge will be to get me to come back and be a user again, I tried it out, then decided it wasn’t for me, as I’m not sure where that data is going and how it’s being used.

    There’s been quite the trend lately of Community Evangelists, in fact I even met a VP of Community Evangelism at the Web 2.0 Expo this week.

    (Left: Dell’s Blog Warrior, Lionel Menchaca)

    I’ve met Lionel Menchaca a few times, I consider him to be one of my peers, as we shared the same experience deploying social media at large tech companies. Today, Lionel visited one of the most well known detractors to the Dell brand, Jeff Jarvis who coined the business blogging case study “Dell Hell”.

    Dell’s Lionel the program manager of the Dell one to one site, and IdeaStorm does blogger relations in real life, here’s what Jeff had to say himself:

    “And there is the genius of Lionel Menchaca. In a flash, he transformed the image of Dell in my eyes. From a company that wanted to look at but not touch people like me, that wanted customers to come deal in the company’s space on the company’s terms, here suddenly was a guy who spoke honestly and directly.”

    You should read directly from Jeff’s blog.

    Related Topics

  • I’m chronicling the Dell Hell to Dell Swell Saga
  • Understanding the Community/Evangelist Role, and profiles of a few of my Favorite Folks
  • Social Media, and the web in general gives way to individuals to connect, in which they share their real human face, thoughts, and opinions.

    One way for companies to adopt to this is to hire or create a role called a “Customer/Community” + “Evangelist/Advocate/Manager/Guy/Girl” or some variation of. I know many of those that are the leaders, and at my previous company, I had that role. They often use the tools that the people in the community use, today, this toolset primarily involves blogs, and is now spreading to video, twitter, and who knows what.

    The rules of a Community Manager are simple, here’s my ideology around it, feel free to share your own:

    This “Customer/Community” + “Evangelist/Advocate/Manager/Guy/Girl” role typically has the following traits:

    1) Community First
    Puts the community or the customers as a priority over the company. This person is an advocate for the customers, and will often go ‘join’ the community, rather than try to build it. (I learned this from Tara)

    2) An Educator, two-ways
    Teaches the community about the company and it’s products, often in a non-invasive manner.

    3) Uses the tools and communication style of the community
    In 2007, this is primarily blogs, online pictures. I see this moving to Video, Twitter, and a vast array of emerging tools.

    4) Puts a Human Face on the company
    This person actually shows their real face, both online and at events. Forget those stock images of the pretty Asian woman at the computer, and use a real person, who can relate to the community.

    5) Not just a Marketing Role
    This is not just a PR or marketing role, this role actually extends to:
    Customer Support
    Product Marketing and Engineering

    6) Knows when to get out of the way
    Sometimes this role is to connect the right people in the company (who know more about the product details) with the right customers. Also this role will connect prospects with customers, in a new form of “customer references”.

    7) Pushes the “Membrane”
    Scoble told me about this in 2005, he pushed the corporate membrane at Microsoft, which is a pliable movable invisible wall. Once he felt he pushed it, and was just about to poke through, he would back off. If Corporate Comms and Management gets uncomfortable with the community manager, then you’re doing the job right.

    Additional Resources:

  • What a Community Manager does
  • Can a Community Manager really sit back and shutup?
  • Project Manager, Product Managers, and Product Marketing Manager
  • Social Media changes Product Managers and Product Marketing
  • Update: Inspiring upcoming potential Christopher Salazar has added some additional thoughts, a must read.

  • Some of the profiles of the Evangelists or Community Advocates in the Technology Industry:

    Guy Kawasaki – Former Apple Evangelist and current VC
    Most well known for being one of Apple’s most vibrant Evangelists, in addition to his many endeavors of his own. Guy is the author of eight books including The Art of the Start, Rules for Revolutionaries, How to Drive Your Competition Crazy, Selling the Dream, and The Macintosh Way. Guy has some of the most infectious evangelism, people are drawn to him, and this was very apparent when he started his blog and it instantly became a hit. Check out his wikipedia profile.

    Damon Billian – PayPal, SimplyHired
    I’ve actually known Damon longer than most folks on this list, I knew him from some mutual friends before I started my career. Damon was one of the early evangelists in the web industry, while at PayPal, he compassionately reached out to customers to help answer their questions. Damon is now involved with SimplyHired and is the Community Manager, I myself have interacted with Damon in the SimplyForums where Damon was facilitating some great discussions. Damon can be found either in Silicon Valley or Thailand visiting his sweetheart or on his blog.

    Scott Beale – Laughing Squid
    Scott is the founder of Laughing Squid Web Hosting for over 10 years, as a well-respected photographer, he takes pictures of community events and personalities and spreads his stickers that end up on all kinds of interesting places. He’s also know for throwing some amazing community parties, all this without pitching his product.

    Tara Hunt – Pinko Marketer, Citizen Agency
    As one of the most visible web company evangelists, Tara’s credited by giving to the community that she serves by becoming one of them, as a result of her generous nature, her former employer Riya yielded incredible early signups for it’s initial launch. She founded the Pinko Marketing religion which spurs an emerging generation of marketers that listen rather than talk. Last summer Tara left Riya to start her own consultancy appropriately named Citizen Agency with sweetheart Chris Messina. Today, Tara’s seen on the speaking circuit, stirring up traditional marketing memes, being a mom, or working hard in her swanky SF office loft near SOMA’s South Park Tech corridor. I’m constantly amazed at her energy, I doubt you’ll be able to keep up, so to learn more check out CenterNetworks has a great interview or check out her blog Horse Pig Cow (or as I affectionately refer to it, Neigh, Snort, Moo) .

    Will Pate, Community Ambassador, Flock/Rockstar
    Out of all the evangelists out there, I’m likely to be the most jealous of Will Pate. Not because of his dashing good looks, (or so my wife tells me) or that he’s constantly surrounded by the ladies, or stylish garb, it’s because he makes it look so easy. I recently caught up with Will at the Community Next conference in Palo Alto and he described his role at Flock to be part community advocate, and part company evangelists. He helped to bring the requirements together, connect them, and build a better product. Today, Will can be found in Toronto, and he’s switched to a part time role at Flock, what’s next for Will? Greatness I’m sure.

    Robert Scoble Geek Blogger – Former Microsoft Blogger, now at PodTech
    The Scoblizer brought a human face to the evil empire. Although an employee, Robert was the biggest critic of Microsoft. He would point to the ‘evil’ faster than anyone else could, centralizing the conversation and opening up a transparent conversation. As a blogging evangelist, Robert changed how many felt about Microsoft. We now work together at PodTech. He’s most often seen in one of our meeting rooms interviewing a CEO for his show ScobleShow.

    Thomas Hawk – Photographer, Zooomr Evangelist

    In my opinion, Thomas has the most unique style, hired a few months ago as Zooomr (a Photo sharing site) as their Marketing Evangelist, rather than pitching the product, he uses his camera. Thomas takes pictures of just about everything and anything, and they all turn out interesting. By being an example of the photographer community, he brings the experience of photo sharing (and that means zooomr) closer to his community. He also never ‘hard-pitches’ his company, buy by just demonstrating his mastery of photography he draws the community in closer.

    Craig Newmark, Founder of Craigslist
    To me, Craig is a very fatherly character in the drama I call the internet. His website is about giving, sharing, and helping others. He’s a serious community guy, who gives his time, effort to those who also need help. If you’ve ever seen him speak, he’s very humble and generous to others.

    Micki Krimmel – Revver
    Micki is the video Starlet of our time. As the Director of Community at Video Sharing site Revver, she walks and talks the business. Her highly captivating videos express her unique style, signature tattoo, and impecable fashion forward LA fashions. If anyone should get her own dedicated video show it should be Micki. I’ve met up with Micki a few times, and her online persona is exactly like her real life one: engaging, interesting, captivating and very babelicious. It’s no doubt that Revver has so wisley chose her to be the front face of the company, like Thomas Hawk, she lives the product without pitching it. But more than anything even Galacticast thinks The Micki is sexy.

    Martin McKeay – StillSecure Blogger, Podcaster, Videoblogger
    Martin is a personal friend of mine, and has recently started as the Security Evangelist for StillSecure a security solutions company. While still too early to sing any praises, we’ll keep an eye on him. Martin is a Security Blogger “A-lister” Podcaster, VideoBlogger (with PodTech), and Speaker.

    Mario Sundar – LinkedIn

    Mario announced his succession as the Community Evangelist at Linkedin a few hours ago.

    Others?
    I realize there are other people that could make this list, (such as the wikipedia entry on Technology Evangelist I pulled from those that I’ve met or followed, feel free to add a comment to add your own!

    Who am I? Master Blogger Shel Israel has documented my experience as the Online Community Manager at Hitachi Data Systems. I now work as a social media consultant at PodTech, helping our clients with their own Community.

    Update: I’m no longer at Podtech, but instead am an Analyst at Forrester Research covering Social Computing, in fact, I’ve published a report on this passion topic of mine, how to staff for social computing.

    site design by studionashvegas proudly powered by WordPress